Best Subject-Specific Homeschool Curriculum: Saxon Math, Math-U-See, and All About Reading (2026-2027)

Updated for the 2026-2027 school year

Not every family needs a full curriculum package. Sometimes you have a great core program but need a stronger math component. Or your child is struggling with reading and you need a specialized program to fill that gap. That is where subject-specific curriculum comes in.

The three programs we hear about most from homeschool families are Saxon Math, Math-U-See, and All About Reading (and its companion, All About Spelling). Each takes a very different approach to teaching foundational skills, and the right one depends entirely on how your child learns.

Let us break them down.

Saxon Math

What It Is

Saxon Math is one of the most established math programs in the homeschool world. It covers kindergarten through advanced high school math (including calculus) and is known for its incremental, spiral approach. That means new concepts are introduced in small steps and then reviewed continuously throughout the rest of the course.

How It Teaches

Saxon breaks every lesson into a short instruction section followed by a mixed practice set. The practice sets include problems from the current lesson plus review problems from everything the student has learned so far. This constant review is the core of Saxon's philosophy — students never move on and forget.

The program is straightforward and predictable. There are no games, no colorful illustrations, and very little hand-holding. It is a math program that treats math as a skill to be practiced daily, like a musical instrument.

Pricing

Saxon Math textbooks typically run $50 to $80 per level for the student edition. Home study kits that include the teacher's manual and test booklet run $80 to $130. Used copies are widely available and significantly cheaper since the content has not changed much between editions.

Who Saxon Math Is Best For

• Students who benefit from daily, consistent practice with continuous review
• Families who want a no-frills, proven math program without digital components
• Kids preparing for standardized tests — Saxon students consistently score well on math assessments
• Students who need repetition to retain concepts (the spiral approach is built for this)
• High schoolers who need a rigorous transcript-ready math program through calculus

Honest Pros and Cons

What families love:

• The spiral review is genuinely effective — kids remember what they learn
• Strong standardized test performance
• Clear, predictable lesson structure
• Excellent for building math confidence through consistent practice
• Affordable, especially used

What to watch out for:

• Can feel repetitive and boring for kids who grasp concepts quickly
• The plain, text-heavy format is not engaging for visual or kinesthetic learners
• Problem sets are long — some kids hit fatigue before they finish
• Does not develop deep conceptual understanding as well as some newer programs

Math-U-See

What It Is

Math-U-See is a mastery-based math program that covers PreK through pre-calculus. Created by Steve Demme, it uses physical manipulatives (colored blocks) alongside video instruction to teach math concepts in a multi-sensory way. Students master one concept completely before moving to the next.

How It Teaches

The approach is the opposite of Saxon's spiral. Instead of reviewing everything constantly, Math-U-See focuses on one concept per lesson until the student demonstrates mastery. The physical manipulatives let kids literally build and see math problems — addition becomes combining blocks, place value becomes stacking units and tens.

Each lesson starts with a short video from Steve Demme demonstrating the concept with manipulatives. Then the student practices with their own blocks before transitioning to paper-based work. This progression from hands-on to abstract is the heart of the program.

Pricing

A Math-U-See level set (student workbook, teacher guide, test booklet, and video access) runs approximately $110 to $135. The manipulative block set is a one-time purchase of about $55 that is used across all levels. Total first-year cost is around $165 to $190, with subsequent years running $110 to $135.

Who Math-U-See Is Best For

• Kids who are visual or hands-on learners — the manipulatives make abstract concepts concrete
• Students with learning differences (ADHD, dyslexia, dyscalculia) — the multi-sensory approach works well for many of these learners
• Children who struggled with other math programs — Math-U-See often clicks for kids who hit walls elsewhere
• Families who want video instruction so the parent does not have to teach math directly
• Younger students (K through 6) — the manipulatives are most valuable in the early years

Honest Pros and Cons

What families love:

• The manipulatives genuinely help kids understand math, not just memorize procedures
• Video lessons mean you do not have to be a math teacher yourself
• Mastery approach means no gaps — kids truly understand before moving on
• Outstanding for kids with learning differences
• Gentle, encouraging teaching style

What to watch out for:

• Mastery approach can feel slow — some kids are ready to move on before the program lets them
• Less review of previous concepts compared to spiral programs
• Students switching from spiral programs may have placement challenges
• The manipulatives become less central in the upper levels

All About Reading and All About Spelling

What They Are

All About Reading (AAR) and All About Spelling (AAS) are Orton-Gillingham-based programs that teach reading and spelling through a structured, multi-sensory approach. Developed by Marie Rippel, both programs use a combination of letter tiles, flashcards, games, and activities to build phonics skills systematically.

How They Teach

Both programs are parent-led — you work one-on-one with your child through short daily lessons. All About Reading has four levels (Pre-reading through Level 4) that take a student from letter sounds through fluent reading. All About Spelling has seven levels that build spelling skills from basic phonograms through advanced patterns.

The Orton-Gillingham method these programs are built on was originally developed for students with dyslexia, which means the instruction is unusually thorough and multi-sensory. Students see, hear, say, and physically manipulate letters and words during every lesson.

Pricing

• All About Reading: Each level runs approximately $80 to $120 for the complete package (teacher's manual, student packet, reader, letter tiles). The interactive kit with reading games is about $25 extra.
• All About Spelling: Each level runs approximately $40 to $60 for the materials. The basic letter tiles kit ($25) is used across all levels.
• Total investment: A full run through all AAR and AAS levels comes to roughly $500 to $700 over several years.

Who AAR and AAS Are Best For

• Kids with dyslexia or other reading difficulties — this is one of the most highly recommended programs for struggling readers
• Any child learning to read who benefits from systematic, structured phonics
• Families who want a multi-sensory approach to reading and spelling
• Parents who want scripted lessons with exactly what to say and do — no guessing
• Kids who need slow, thorough instruction rather than being rushed through phonics

Honest Pros and Cons

What families love:

• Incredibly effective for struggling readers — many families call it life-changing
• The scripted lessons make teaching easy even for parents with no teaching experience
• Multi-sensory activities keep kids engaged during lessons
• Works well for kids with and without learning differences
• Excellent customer support and active online community

What to watch out for:

• Requires one-on-one parent time for every lesson — not a program kids can do independently
• Pace may feel slow for kids who pick up reading quickly
• The program is reading and spelling only — you will need a separate writing and grammar curriculum
• Cost adds up across multiple levels if you have several children (though materials are reusable)

Which Math Program? Saxon vs Math-U-See

This is the question that launches a thousand homeschool forum debates. Here is the simplest way to decide:

• Choose Saxon Math if your child does well with daily written practice, benefits from constant review, and you want a straightforward, no-frills program with a strong track record on standardized tests.
• Choose Math-U-See if your child is a visual or hands-on learner, has struggled with other math programs, or needs a gentler, mastery-based approach that builds understanding from the ground up.

Building a Custom Curriculum Stack

One of the advantages of subject-specific programs is the ability to build a custom combination that fits your child perfectly. Here is a popular stack that many homeschool families use:

1. Core curriculum (Abeka, BJU Press, Sonlight, etc.) for history, science, and general instruction
2. Saxon Math or Math-U-See to replace the math component if the core math is not clicking
3. All About Reading for early reading instruction or reading remediation
4. All About Spelling alongside whatever language arts program you are using

This mix-and-match approach lets you keep what is working from your main curriculum while upgrading the subjects where your child needs something different.

Want more curriculum guides? Check out our Guide to Traditional Homeschool Curriculum or follow us on Pinterest for weekly homeschool resources.